SmashWiki:New Logo Proposal 2

As there has been significant feedback on the idea of a possible new logo, there is now an official proposal, initiated by Mako Shark and added to by Toomai.

Proposal A	Proposal B	Proposal C	Current Logo

Users may vote on which logo they prefer. This is not strictly a majority-wins vote; if it is too close to call there may be a revote between the winners.

Note that this does not affect the old SmashWikia. Feedback is still welcome here. Shark (talk) 01:18, 15 October 2010 (EDT) Toomai Glittershine 09:39, 15 October 2010 (EDT)

Votes for Proposal A

1. --Vincent Tran 02:43, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
2. Support I find this logo to be more representative of the Smash series than the old logo. A cartoonish logo is more fitting for a Wiki about cartoonish games. Omega Tyrant 04:09, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
3. Massive support For reasons stated above. Mr. Anon (talk) 19:34, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
4. Support I feel childish after listening to Epic Yarn's epic remixes.--MegaTron1XD 15:54, 16 October 2010 (EDT)

Votes for Proposal B

1. I must say I find this wikipedia style logo quite enticing.-Ivy73 18:10, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
2. I gotta agree and it does look really Nintendo-y -Scoobford (talk) 19:03, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
3. I feel that this wiki should be distanced from the Wikia one. Changing the logo would be good. I know that the logo will be replaced anyway but a new one will be better. I like this one more than the others and have never really liked the old one. ☆The Solar Dragon☆ 12:41, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
4. Nothing to say that hasn't already been said. Unknown the Hedgehog 20:26, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
5. My favorite logo is this one, and if not this one change it to the first one. I really don't want to keep the old logo on this Wiki, because like Solar Dragon said, "I feel that this wiki should be distanced from the Wikia one." Doctor Pain 99 (CTE) 12:44, 18 October 2010 (EDT)

Votes for Proposal C

1. ..
2. ....Mesuxelf (talk) 15:35, 18 October 2010 (EDT)

Votes for Keeping Old Logo

1. There's a difference between "cartoonish" and silly. The new logos, especially A, fall into the latter category. Clarinet Hawk (talk · contributions) 11:43, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
2. Mostly because it's very distinctively SmashWiki, ya know? Second choice (assuming this is IRV) would be Proposal B. Miles (talk) 18:32, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
3. It's not that these logos aren't good, it's that none really beat the current logo --Shaun's Wiji Dodo talk 06:30, 17 October 2010 (EDT)
4. My vote goes from C->Old->B->A in that order, but I'm posting it here because apparently nobody likes C. I do not like A at all :/ – Emmett 18:07, 17 October 2010 (EDT)

Tbh, if we were going to change, I'd support C. Clarinet Hawk (talk · contributions) 23:19, 17 October 2010 (EDT)

Neutral

1. ..

Comments

• Rofl Clarinet Hawk is always so disparaging Shark (talk) 12:04, 15 October 2010 (EDT)

• @OT: What makes you think Smash is a series of cartoony games? Miles (talk) 22:06, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
  • I agree with this sentiment; while Smash Bros. certainly has cartoony physics and has cartoony stuff in it, it also has enough realistic content to the point where blanket-calling it "cartoony" isn't accurate. The Subspace Emissary in particular juxaposes cartoony enemies with realistic textures and environments. Toomai Glittershine 22:21, 15 October 2010 (EDT)
    • The reason why the Smash series is often labled as cartoony is because when compared to most fighting games, such as Mortal Combat, it is indeed cartoony. For example, when one character hit's another, a weird flash happens, rather then a blood splatter or anything else. Correct me if I'm wrong, but also, doesn't the ESRB rating label it for "Cartoon Violence" and "Comic Mischief"? Mr. Anon (talk) 00:50, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
      • That is a bad comparison Anon. For 1, Mortal Kombat is declared the most bloddy fighting game in history. And why should we care too much about what ESRB thinks? I suppose a grenade is cartoony?--MegaTron1XD 00:52, 16 October 2010 (EDT)

• @Miles: Well Miles, if you shoot a rocket launcher at point blank range, will you be completely unharmed? If you hit someone with an double handed, overhand sword swing at full strength, is it going to send the opponent flying up and away? When you hit someone, does comic like flashes appear? Since the beginning, the Smash series has been cartoony and while it has become less so which each installment, it still certainly is. Also, you have to consider that a large amount of the Smash characters are from cartoony games themselves (Mario, Kirby, etc.). But is there anything wrong with it? Absolutely not, but it is rather foolish to pretend the Smash series isn't. Omega Tyrant 06:14, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
  • IMO there's a big difference between "not-cartoony" and "gory." Miles (talk) 12:28, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
    • That doesn't refute what I said, and I can give more examples. When you hit someone high into the sky, are they going to turn into a star or hit a screen? When you punch someone, will comic like flashes appear? Are you going to tell me that getting turned into "trophies" when defeated is realistic? The whole physics of Smash Bros. is cartoonish and not realistic at all. Now, I don't see why you have such a problem with me saying this as it doesn't degrade the series in any way and arguing with me on this does you or this logo proposal any good. The unrealistic, cartoonish things of Smash Bros. are part of what makes the series so great in my opinion. Omega Tyrant 12:40, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
      • The physics of the Smash Bros. universe are cartoony, but the average overall asthetic is not (even the Mario crew get realistic textures), and that clashes with the very-cartoony asthetic of Proposal A. It represents the series in shape but not in art style, and that's why I and others disagree with it. Toomai Glittershine 12:49, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
        • They got some realistic textures, but the Mario crew are still certainly cartoonish looking overall. Also, I never had a problem with you guys disagreeing with it, you're the ones who started this with me for no good reason I can see. Omega Tyrant 13:01, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
          • Relax, OT; this is civilized debate we're going for here. My point was more that describing Smash as cartoony didn't seem to really work for me as Brawl went to great lengths to be less cartoony than every game it drew content from (heck, they even tried to make Toon Link less cel-shaded-looking.) Miles (talk) 14:21, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
            • Less cartoonish =/= not cartoonish. As I said before, each installment was less cartoonish than the previous, but it is still a cartoonish series. I'll also remind you Brawl isn't the only game in the series and people do still play the original and Melee. Your statement about Brawl going to great lengths to be less cartoonish for every game it drew content from is false, I'm certain Snake is closer to cartoonish in Brawl than he is in Metal Gear. Another thing I would like to add is that the logo should be representative for the whole series, not just Brawl. All in all though, I don't see the point of you and Toomai arguing this with me, I'm not changing my opinion and this argument seems unnecessary to me. You shouldn't be telling me to relax when I'm not angry or anything, though I did get a little annoyed when Toomai made it sound like I made a complaint at you guys for not supporting logo A, which I did not said anything to you guys for not supporting it, even when CHawk insulted it. Omega Tyrant 14:46, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
              • Sorry if it appeared that I was saying you made a complaint when you obviously didn't, I was just explaining why I (and other people) don't like Proposal A; as I am basically the main opponent to it (with my proposal(s) being the other possibilities) I feel it's my job to make attempts to sway the voters. Toomai Glittershine 15:01, 16 October 2010 (EDT)
                • Understandable, though I can guarantee you that I'm not going to be swayed. Omega Tyrant 15:16, 16 October 2010 (EDT)