SSBM Icon.png
Competitive.png

Metagame (documentary): Difference between revisions

From SmashWiki, the Super Smash Bros. wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Removed editorialized comment/rhetoric that is inappropriate for a wiki.)
 
(11 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 17: Line 17:
|distributor      =  
|distributor      =  
}}
}}
'''Metagame''' is an nine-part documentary series produced by Travis "{{Sm|Samox}}" Beauchamp and is a follow up to his earlier work, ''[[The Smash Brothers]]''. The series premiered on [[Twitch]] on December 11th-13th, 2020 and was released for purchase on Vimeo on January 29th, 2021.
'''Metagame''' is an award winning eight-part documentary series produced by Travis "{{Sm|Samox}}" Beauchamp and is a follow up to his earlier work, ''[[The Smash Brothers]]''. The series premiered on [[Twitch]] on December 11th-13th, 2020 and was released for purchase on Vimeo on January 29th, 2021. A bonus episode featuring {{Sm|Leffen}} was released June 6th, 2021.


The series focuses on the "[[Super Smash Bros. Melee in competitive play#The "Dark Age" and the era of "The Five Gods" (2008-2013)|Five Gods]]" of ''[[Super Smash Bros. Melee]]'', in addition to {{Sm|Leffen}}, through their competitive history from 2008 through 2015.
The series focuses on the "[[Super Smash Bros. Melee in competitive play#The "Dark Age" and the era of "The Five Gods" (2008-2013)|Five Gods]]" of ''[[Super Smash Bros. Melee]]'', in addition to {{Sm|Leffen}}, through their competitive history from 2008 through 2015.  


==Episodes==
==Episodes==
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|+ Metagame Episodes
|+ Metagame Episodes
Line 79: Line 78:


According to Beauchamp, the documentary had gone through many re-writes and the revisions that the original documentary hadn't gone through. Additionally, due to him seeking more than just a [[YouTube]] release, Beauchamp had to track down the owners of many ''Melee''-related videos throughout many different countries.<ref>[https://www.patreon.com/posts/final-metagame-44823228 "Final Metagame Production Update" - Samox's Patreon]</ref>
According to Beauchamp, the documentary had gone through many re-writes and the revisions that the original documentary hadn't gone through. Additionally, due to him seeking more than just a [[YouTube]] release, Beauchamp had to track down the owners of many ''Melee''-related videos throughout many different countries.<ref>[https://www.patreon.com/posts/final-metagame-44823228 "Final Metagame Production Update" - Samox's Patreon]</ref>
In the summer of 2020, many prominent figures in the community had to be cut at the last minute due to [[2020 Super Smash Bros. sexual misconduct allegations|allegations of sexual misconduct towards them]].


On November 23rd, 2020, a trailer released, along with the announcement that the series would premiere on Twitch on December 11th-13th, 2020.<ref>https://www.metagamedoc.com/</ref> Episodes 1-3 aired on December 11th at 2-5 p.m. PT, Episodes 4-6 aired on December 12th at 2-5 p.m. PT, and Episodes 7-8 aired on December 13th at 2-4 p.m. PT.
On November 23rd, 2020, a trailer released, along with the announcement that the series would premiere on Twitch on December 11th-13th, 2020.<ref>https://www.metagamedoc.com/</ref> Episodes 1-3 aired on December 11th at 2-5 p.m. PT, Episodes 4-6 aired on December 12th at 2-5 p.m. PT, and Episodes 7-8 aired on December 13th at 2-4 p.m. PT.
Line 87: Line 88:


==Reception==
==Reception==
The release of the documentary's first three episodes resulted in the hashtag "metagame" rising to #2 on the United States trending page of [[Twitter]].<ref>[https://twitter.com/metagamedoc/status/1337535302722756610 #2 on U.S. Trending]</ref>
{{Citations missing}}The release of the documentary's first three episodes resulted in the hashtag "metagame" rising to #2 on the United States trending page of [[Twitter]].<ref>[https://twitter.com/metagamedoc/status/1337535302722756610 #2 on U.S. Trending]</ref> and the entire initial screening was viewed more than 1 million times.
 
The documentary received a mixed reception upon its initial premiere. The presentation received near-universal praise, frequently considered a massive improvement over [[The Smash Brothers]] on a technical level. The music was also regarded as high quality and heightened the emotions of the scene. However, some say the cinematographers and artist got too ambitious with the visuals, often over dramatizing events.
 
Some players prominently featured in the documentary such as {{Sm|Mango}} and {{Sm|Leffen}} publicly criticized it for not adequately providing the view the context of the time period and how old the players were during filming. Critics argued that their depictions in the documentary were biased with the editing and music choices that over villainized the players. Critics also argued that it did not focus equally on all of the featured players, depicting {{Sm|PPMD}} as the "protagonist" who received the most attention while only identifying {{Sm|Mew2King}} and {{Sm|Hungrybox}} as "gods" and giving them comparatively little screen time.


The documentary received a mixed reception upon its initial premiere. The presentation received near-universal praise, frequently considered a massive improvement over [[The Smash Brothers]] on a technical level. The music was also regarded as high quality and heightened the emotions of the scene. However, some say the cinematographers and artist got too ambitious with the visuals, often dramatizing events to extreme level when it was not warranted. Many also questioned why the documentary stopped at Apex 2015, as many notable events occured between then and the release of the docu-series. The reason for this was that the docu-series lingered in development hell as Beauchamp spent years getting clearance for the use of copyrighted material.
Beauchamp responded to criticism of the initial screening by removing some scenes and giving a stronger censor pass for offensive language. These changes were reflected in final cuts released in 2021. Though Beauchamp could not change the narrative structure of the original 8 episodes, he also produced a special bonus episode called 'God Slayer' featuring Leffen and filmed one-on-one interviews with each god for a special 'gods respond' event which was also viewed more than 1 million times. 'Godslayer' was released in June 2021 and provided Leffen's view of the time period and events covered in Metagame.


Some players prominently featured in the documentary such as {{Sm|Mango}} and {{Sm|Leffen}} publicly criticized it, arguing that their depictions in the documentary were unfairly biased as a result of excessive focus on their past personal actions as well as editing and music choices surrounding their appearances in the documentary. Mango specifically, who was a teenager during the recording of the footage, was shown making derogatory statements in a not so subtle attempt to villainize him. Many claimed that this depiction is unfair and damaging, as the clips were taken out of context when it was more socially acceptable to say such things. Leffen was also depicted as a stereotypical villain with no redeeming qualities, despite many believing he had redeemed himself and has returned to being a respected member of the community. Critics of the documentary also argued that it did not focus equally on all of the featured players, depicting {{Sm|PPMD}} as the "protagonist" who received the most attention while only identifying {{Sm|Mew2King}} and {{Sm|Hungrybox}} as "gods" and giving them comparatively little screen time compared to the others. While this bias can be chalked up to it being the personal perspective of Beauchamp, it still remains an issue when trying to remain objective.
Final cuts of the series are being reviewed favorably on IMDB with a rating 9.5. Metagame Documentary was a finalist for 3 esport awards in 2021 including esport content series of the year, esport content piece of the year, and esport video production team of the year. Metagame ultimately was named and won esport content series of the year for 2021.


Beauchamp himself has been criticized for his inablity to take constructive criticism. While eventually removing aspects of Mango and Leffen in future editions, many believed those actions were only done to stave off criticism without him knowing why the criticism exists in the first place. A specific instance is the topic of "Gamer Language," which is a coded phrase meaning racist, sexist, homophobic, and otherwise insensitive language that was commonplace years ago and still exists, though not as prevelent, to this day. While referenced frequently, the use of Gamer Language was never properly called out or criticized, while having subtle moments where Beauchamp finds the concept humorous. Despite this attitude, the docu-series had moments of censorship that seemed bizzare in context. An example is Armada calling Jigglypuff “gay” is bleeped out, Mango calling PPMD “bisexual” is not bleeped. This selective censorship seems to uphold the narrative Beauchamp wants to tell while downplaying any other perspective.
===Censorship Allegations===
Following the release of Metagame, the documentary was revised to remove mentions of [[Evidence.zip]], a 2013 controversy where Leffen was banned for harassing players in the Swedish ''Melee'' scene.  


While not directly related to the quality of docu-series, many prominent figures in the community had to be cut at the last minute due to allegations of sexual misconduct towards them. Beauchamp made a statement saying he managed to remove these figures entirely and replace them with new ones. Many claimed that this was the wrong method of addressing the situation, as simply sweeping the situation under the rug and pretending it never happened helps no one and can stifle awareness to those not in the inner community circles.  
On 14th August 2021, this revision would be severely criticised by {{Sm|Hax$}} as part of a video titled "Evidence.zip 3"<ref>[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msy4E3ScZVk Evidence.zip 3]</ref>. In the video, Hax$ accused the documentary of lying about Leffen's past controversies and censoring Evidence.zip's existence. Hax$ would later cite the Metagame documentary as a primary reason for his erratic behaviour, albeit not directly apologise for his critiques<ref>[https://twitter.com/ssbmhax/status/1441537392226316304 Hax$ Apology Tweet]</ref>.


Overall, Metagame should not be automatically disregarded, as it provides interesting takes on people that shaped a community and helped make a generation of professional video game players. However, the amount of bias and cherry picking of narratives on display do bring the series down from being considered one of the great documentaries. Still, it provides genuine and valuable insight on the competitive scene in an entertaining way, which is the reason it exists in the first place.
On 25th January 2024, Samox would release a statement on the matter<ref>[https://twitter.com/_samox_/status/1750634235461865944 Samox's Statement]</ref>. Here, he would note that the Evidence.zip clips totalled around 20 seconds of runtime and that Leffen remained portrayed in a negative light in the video. Most notably, however, he revealed that a party shown in the Evidence.zip clips threatened to sue Metagame for their inclusion, forcing their silent removal from the documentary. He specifically noted that this party was not Leffen. Despite this, the censorship allegations were repeated by Hax$ in a January 2024 video titled "The Truth"<ref>[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jn_J19CgFzo&t=476s&ab_channel=AzizAl-Yami "The Truth"]</ref>.


==References==
==References==

Latest revision as of 17:29, January 28, 2024

Metagame
Logo for the Metagame documentary.
Released December 11th-13th, 2020 (Episode 1-8 Premiere)
January 29th, 2021 (Vimeo)
June 6th, 2021 (Bonus Episode Premiere)
Runtime 7 hours, 24 minutes
Language(s) English
Budget $34,583
Crew
Director(s) Travis Beauchamp
Producer(s) Christopher Brown
Peter N. Grant Sr.
Art Director(s) Daniel Wyatt
Narrator(s) Nick Papoutsakis
Music by Garrett Williamson
Lord Dinosaur
Melo
Jesse Beauchamp

Metagame is an award winning eight-part documentary series produced by Travis "Samox" Beauchamp and is a follow up to his earlier work, The Smash Brothers. The series premiered on Twitch on December 11th-13th, 2020 and was released for purchase on Vimeo on January 29th, 2021. A bonus episode featuring Leffen was released June 6th, 2021.

The series focuses on the "Five Gods" of Super Smash Bros. Melee, in addition to Leffen, through their competitive history from 2008 through 2015.

Episodes[edit]

Metagame Episodes
# Title Logline
1 A Beautiful Accident Our story begins in the misty far away days of the 1990s - the golden age of console gaming. It was in this rush to produce new and engaging multiplayer experiences that Nintendo created A Beautiful Accident - Super Smash Brothers Melee.

The ostensibly casual and kid-oriented game would reveal itself to be far deeper than any fighting game in the world - and soon fostered a dedicated community of competitive players around it.

2 The Kid Mango’s abilities confound his opponents, but his victories are undeniable. With a clear dominance of the game, Mango shifts the center of the Melee universe to the West Coast of the USA and his scrappy Norwalk neighborhood.

Across the Atlantic, a Peach player from Europe starts to make waves; some even say he is the best in the world. International tensions run high as the news breaks that he will be traveling to America for the first time.

When Armada pushes Mango to limits he’s never faced, will The Kid from Norwalk break?

3 The Limiter A shy kid from a small town, PPMD must discover who he is in a new competitive gaming world; desperate to overcome his regional nemesis Hungrybox, but also hoping to make friends and fit in.

When a half-retired Mango takes the young Falco player as a disciple, he grows in leaps and bounds - but struggles to move past The Limiter he has erected in his mind.

With Armada devising a secret weapon to unleash upon his return to America, PP emerges as America’s last best hope.

4 Fire on the Mountain Years of competition have taught Armada that you can’t get to your goal right away - you must earn it with hard work. But after constant defeats, Armada’s confidence in ever finding a victory in America begins to wane.

In his time of need, a little piece of high school wisdom on a forgotten mural reminds the Swede of the fire which drives him on.

With Mango making a return using the game’s fastest character and all eyes on a massive summer tournament, Armada sees his chance to finally seize the Fire on the Mountain top.

5 The Tao of Smash After years of struggling against Mango both in-game and out of it, PPMD takes aim at his one time teacher. Seeking to understand what makes the kid from Norwalk so different, PP begins a journey into The Tao of Smash with a new teacher - Cactuar.

Meanwhile, Armada seeks to stack up more victories in the coming tournaments; but as they come, he notices a growing emptiness within himself.

The times they are a changing…

6 Sunday in America With a sudden explosion of popularity in streaming and a renewed interest in the game, it’s Sunday in America for the members of the Pantheon and the smash community.

But as Armada finds his fire again, he comes face to face with a player he betrayed. Leffen seeks his revenge on his former playing partner and aims to become the “One True God”.

Will the Pantheon fall to the brash “god slayer”?

7 The Pantheon's Fall pt. 1 As hype builds for the largest tournament of all time at Apex 2015, the gods each prepare in their own ways. PPMD works to control his inner demons as Armada reveals a secret weapon at the last Apex Qualifier.

Meanwhile, Leffen’s incessant trash talk leads old-school legend Chillindude to challenge him to a money match, slated for the Apex Salty Suite.

Tensions near the boiling point in The Pantheon’s Fall Part 1.

8 The Pantheon's Fall pt. 2 The final showdown arrives for everyone in The Pantheon’s Fall Part 2. After nearly being canceled once the original venue falls through, Apex is saved in a massive volunteer effort by the players themselves.

In the hectic final days, the fate of the Pantheon, the god-slayer and the game itself all unfold in front of over a hundred thousand viewers watching live around the world.

Bonus Godslayer The story of the Pantheon's Fall is now told from Leffen's perspective as the young Swede battles to end the Era of the 5 Gods and take revenge on the top players of smash brothers.

Production[edit]

The documentary took over five years to produce following the release of the original documentary, The Smash Brothers. A kickstarter for a continuation of The Smash Brothers was launched on April 14th, 2014. Its goal of $26,000 was surpassed only two weeks after a launch and would total up to $34,583. This continuation of The Smash Brothers would eventually form into Metagame.

According to Beauchamp, the documentary had gone through many re-writes and the revisions that the original documentary hadn't gone through. Additionally, due to him seeking more than just a YouTube release, Beauchamp had to track down the owners of many Melee-related videos throughout many different countries.[1]

In the summer of 2020, many prominent figures in the community had to be cut at the last minute due to allegations of sexual misconduct towards them.

On November 23rd, 2020, a trailer released, along with the announcement that the series would premiere on Twitch on December 11th-13th, 2020.[2] Episodes 1-3 aired on December 11th at 2-5 p.m. PT, Episodes 4-6 aired on December 12th at 2-5 p.m. PT, and Episodes 7-8 aired on December 13th at 2-4 p.m. PT.

The documentary was uploaded for purchase via Vimeo on January 29th, 2021. This version of the documentary features edits in response to viewer feedback, particularly in regard to offensive language deemed appropriate at the time and the negative portrayal of Leffen.[3]

On April 24th, 2021, it was announced there would be a three-day special event in June with a livestream of all eight episodes, new interviews with all five gods and Leffen, and a special feature and a new episode called "Metagame: Godslayer."[4] On May 15th, 2021, it was announced the livestream to be a two-day event on June 5th-6th, 2021, starting at 10 a.m. PT each day.[5] A new trailer was uploaded the same day.[6] Day 1 of the stream had interviews with Mew2King, Armada, Hungrybox, and Mango in between episodes.[7] Day 2 of the stream had interviews with PPMD and Leffen in between episodes.[8] Day 1 had Episodes 1-4 and Day 2 had Episodes 5-8 and the premiere of the new episode, "Godslayer".

Reception[edit]

The release of the documentary's first three episodes resulted in the hashtag "metagame" rising to #2 on the United States trending page of Twitter.[9] and the entire initial screening was viewed more than 1 million times.

The documentary received a mixed reception upon its initial premiere. The presentation received near-universal praise, frequently considered a massive improvement over The Smash Brothers on a technical level. The music was also regarded as high quality and heightened the emotions of the scene. However, some say the cinematographers and artist got too ambitious with the visuals, often over dramatizing events.

Some players prominently featured in the documentary such as Mango and Leffen publicly criticized it for not adequately providing the view the context of the time period and how old the players were during filming. Critics argued that their depictions in the documentary were biased with the editing and music choices that over villainized the players. Critics also argued that it did not focus equally on all of the featured players, depicting PPMD as the "protagonist" who received the most attention while only identifying Mew2King and Hungrybox as "gods" and giving them comparatively little screen time.

Beauchamp responded to criticism of the initial screening by removing some scenes and giving a stronger censor pass for offensive language. These changes were reflected in final cuts released in 2021. Though Beauchamp could not change the narrative structure of the original 8 episodes, he also produced a special bonus episode called 'God Slayer' featuring Leffen and filmed one-on-one interviews with each god for a special 'gods respond' event which was also viewed more than 1 million times. 'Godslayer' was released in June 2021 and provided Leffen's view of the time period and events covered in Metagame.

Final cuts of the series are being reviewed favorably on IMDB with a rating 9.5. Metagame Documentary was a finalist for 3 esport awards in 2021 including esport content series of the year, esport content piece of the year, and esport video production team of the year. Metagame ultimately was named and won esport content series of the year for 2021.

Censorship Allegations[edit]

Following the release of Metagame, the documentary was revised to remove mentions of Evidence.zip, a 2013 controversy where Leffen was banned for harassing players in the Swedish Melee scene.

On 14th August 2021, this revision would be severely criticised by Hax$ as part of a video titled "Evidence.zip 3"[10]. In the video, Hax$ accused the documentary of lying about Leffen's past controversies and censoring Evidence.zip's existence. Hax$ would later cite the Metagame documentary as a primary reason for his erratic behaviour, albeit not directly apologise for his critiques[11].

On 25th January 2024, Samox would release a statement on the matter[12]. Here, he would note that the Evidence.zip clips totalled around 20 seconds of runtime and that Leffen remained portrayed in a negative light in the video. Most notably, however, he revealed that a party shown in the Evidence.zip clips threatened to sue Metagame for their inclusion, forcing their silent removal from the documentary. He specifically noted that this party was not Leffen. Despite this, the censorship allegations were repeated by Hax$ in a January 2024 video titled "The Truth"[13].

References[edit]

External links[edit]