Talk:Steve

"Genderless"

Is it really accurate to say Steve is genderless? I think "sexless" would be more accurate, if at all - I say that since 1. Notch is no longer involved with Minecraft, and Alex (the first female skin) was introduced not that long after he left; and 2. Notch is a known transphobe so it's unlikely he'd make the distinction between sex and gender, especially not in 2012. --What could possibly go wrong? - BubzieBobkat (talk) 01:53, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

I agree with both of these statements, but to my knowledge it's still the latest official word that Minecraft is "genderless" rather than "sexless", and the way he phrases it implies it lacks both sex and gender (animals have male and female aspects and any of one species can breed with any other). It's weird, considering he wrote in the blog post that he wishes he had used the singular "they" rather than "he" to describe Steve, but he for some reason holds totally opposing ideals now. It's also worth keeping in mind that Alex isn't referred to as female just as Steve isn't referred to as male (though I've noticed promo material uses "he" and "she" anyway, so maybe sexless would be more accurate?). I think the overall idea is that sex and gender are non-issues in the world of Minecraft so calling it "sexless" or "genderless" doesn't really matter one way or the other. ~ Serena Strawberry (talk) 02:40, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

Can you link to promo material calling Steve a "he" and Alex a "she"? If those were after Notch made those comments about Steve being genderless, then they would probably be above those due to being more recent. 72.219.72.215 15:17, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

Here's an example of Steve being referred to as "he" in 2020. But it doesn't necessarily invalidate the original claim, as the same comment about Minecraft being genderless uses "he" to describe Steve. ~ Serena Strawberry (talk) 15:59, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

The genderless article uses "he" in quotes, clearly indicating that they are intentionally using the wrong pronoun.

Smells like a retcon to me. TheNuttyOne 16:08, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

I didn't really interpret it like that, but I guess either way we'll see which pronouns to use by the Mr. Sakurai Presents about it; I wouldn't be surprised if they did use "he" and "she". (Though in that case it'd just be changing "genderless" to "sexless", as Bubzie suggested.) ~ Serena Strawberry (talk) 16:15, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

Steve and Alex on the same page

Should Alex really be grouped with Steve? Zombie and Enderman have separate pages as well as other alternate characters like Alph and the Koopalings. I think Alex should have her own page. Diddy Kongstar (talk) 12:41, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

• My nitpicky side agrees, but in all honesty Alex doesn't really have a history beyond "there's not enough girls in this game" "we added a girl" "thank you" so it's probably best to lump her in with Steve. --What could possibly go wrong? - BubzieBobkat (talk) 14:01, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

Alex is more in line with Leaf or female Byleth (who also has a different name in Japanese) than Alph or the Koopalings. She is a female variant of Steve; she was just given the name Alex. TheNuttyOne 15:35, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

Agreed on this. ~ Serena Strawberry (talk) 15:59, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

While Steve and Alex definitely belong on the same page, I think the page should be renamed to "Steve & Alex" or "Steve/Alex". Unlike with Red and Leaf, who share a page under the same title, Steve and Alex are just referred to as their names in-game. Leaving Alex out of a page title feels a little unfair. Personally, I'm leaning towards to "Steve/Alex" option, because it is how they are referred to as on the official website. Xm0c (talk) 18:28, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

This I can also see the case for, as Steve and Alex are both given equal priority, but at the same time, it would make things a bit more clunky compared to "Steve" being simple and consistent, and it's likely that in-game text will default to just "Steve" as well. I could also make a case for changing the article name to merely "Player (Minecraft)", matching the Minecraft wiki, but that'd probably be even more confusing. ~ Serena Strawberry (talk) 18:40, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

While "Player (Minecraft)" would make sense, every fighter uses either their in-game name, or in cases like Fox McCloud, their full name referenced in the game. I don't think having the dash in the title would be a huge problem, especially because there is precedent with Burning Knuckle / Crack Shoot. Xm0c (talk) 19:25, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

"Player (Minecraft)" would make sense, if they weren't called "Steve" and "Alex" in-game. The same goes for the protagonists from Persona 3 and Persona 4, but for the opposite reason; they are not called Makoto Yuki and Yu Narukami in Smash, so we use the generic term. Aidan, the Spooky Rurouni 19:33, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

I'm thinking Steve/Alex for the character page but Steve SSBU for the fighter page. If the main website considers Alex important enough to mention in the title then I think we should too. Guybrush20X6 (talk) 19:58, October 2, 2020 (EDT)

I could understand the comparison with Leaf and Female Byleth in Japan, but Smash just uses Pokémon Trainer for both Red and Leaf and Byleth has the same name in English regardless of gender. Steve and Alex are different cases from these as they have different names in all regions and in Smash. Diddy Kongstar (talk) 22:39, October 2, 2020 (EDT)