SmashWiki talk:Article of the Week: Difference between revisions
From SmashWiki, the Super Smash Bros. wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (→Current votes) |
MaskedMarth (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
===[[Luigi (SSBM)]]=== | ===[[Luigi (SSBM)]]=== | ||
*'''Nom & For''': I remember the votes against [[Mewtwo (SSBM)]] on here some time ago, stating that the extreme detail on that page effectively scares away readers. This Luigi page appears to conform much better with what voters expect from a page on a playable fighter appearing in a specific Smash game; His pros and cons section is well-written prose, his big move-descriptions section is appealing to me personally (especially without a bunch of giant GIFs clogging up the page), and his unlock method is near the top where it should be. I'm also aware this was nominated three months ago and failed, but [http://www.smashwiki.com/w/index.php?title=Luigi_%28SSBM%29&diff=28322&oldid=16442 this] is the editing that has occured to it since then. [[User:Erik the Appreciator|Erik the Appreciator]] 16:35, June 18, 2007 (EDT) | *'''Nom & For''': I remember the votes against [[Mewtwo (SSBM)]] on here some time ago, stating that the extreme detail on that page effectively scares away readers. This Luigi page appears to conform much better with what voters expect from a page on a playable fighter appearing in a specific Smash game; His pros and cons section is well-written prose, his big move-descriptions section is appealing to me personally (especially without a bunch of giant GIFs clogging up the page), and his unlock method is near the top where it should be. I'm also aware this was nominated three months ago and failed, but [http://www.smashwiki.com/w/index.php?title=Luigi_%28SSBM%29&diff=28322&oldid=16442 this] is the editing that has occured to it since then. [[User:Erik the Appreciator|Erik the Appreciator]] 16:35, June 18, 2007 (EDT) | ||
*'''For''', for the same reasons as before. I'll try to touch it up before it goes up. {{User:MaskedMarth/sig}} 15:43, June 23, 2007 (EDT) | |||
== Previous nominations == | == Previous nominations == | ||
Revision as of 15:43, June 23, 2007
Here is where you can discuss what the upcoming Articles of the Week should be. Next week's article needs to be chosen, so discuss here!
- NOTE: It would be better if we got ahead of schedule on the Articles of the Week - this means we should have both more nominations and more votes. You may vote for more than one article at a time.
Rules for Selection
- Any user may nominate an article for selection as Article of the Week.
- Other users shall vote on whether it is well-written enough to merit being featured on the Main Page. You may suggest improvements to the article during this process.
- If the vote results in a general consensus for the article's selection, a sysop may select the article to appear as a future Article of the Week.
- Any number of articles may be up for a vote simultaneously.
- Once an article is either featured as article of the week or is determined to have failed the vote, its nomination shall be moved to an appropriate subpage.
These rules are tentative and can be changed if necessary.
Current votes
Luigi (SSBM)
- Nom & For: I remember the votes against Mewtwo (SSBM) on here some time ago, stating that the extreme detail on that page effectively scares away readers. This Luigi page appears to conform much better with what voters expect from a page on a playable fighter appearing in a specific Smash game; His pros and cons section is well-written prose, his big move-descriptions section is appealing to me personally (especially without a bunch of giant GIFs clogging up the page), and his unlock method is near the top where it should be. I'm also aware this was nominated three months ago and failed, but this is the editing that has occured to it since then. Erik the Appreciator 16:35, June 18, 2007 (EDT)
- For, for the same reasons as before. I'll try to touch it up before it goes up. – MaskedMarth (t c) 15:43, June 23, 2007 (EDT)
Previous nominations
See previous nominations on the below archive page(s):
