Editing Forum:Rankings categories

{{forumheader|Proposals}}<!-- Please put your content below this line. Be sure to sign your edits with four tildes: ~~~~ -->
{{Proposal|passed}}

Back in 2015, a user named {{user|Dinodomain}} started creating categories for each iteration of [[SSBMRank]] on their own imperative, and outside of mild questioning on his [[User talk:Dinodomain#Hey...|talk page]], other users just started following suit with creating categories for the other annual/biannual global rankings whenever those rankings got made, with no one really challenging their existence. Me and several other users however, have expressed in the Discord server for the past couple years how these categories should be purged. There are two main problems with these categories:

1: For the purpose of cataloging the players that made each ranking, they're useless; you can simply just go on the actual article for the ranking to see the players who were on that particular ranking, and not only will it be more neatly organized, you'll also get additional important information that won't be displayed on the category page, such as the player's ranking and the character(s) they used for that ranking period.

2: These categories just serve to cause massive category bloat; top level and near top level players will often make several iterations of these rankings, so such players will often have their categories bloat to eyesore levels, the majority of that bloat being these mostly redundant categories. For example, {{Sm|Dabuz}} currently has 25 categories, yet 11 of these categories are for specific iterations of these rankings. Or {{Sm|Mango}}, who has a whopping 33 categories, yet these make up 14 of those categories.

A single category for each type of ranking (e.g. one for [[SSBMRank]], one for [[PGR]], one for [[UltRank]], etc.) would suffice, showing all the players that once made that ranking, providing useful cataloging information that isn't immediately accessible elsewhere without bloating each player's categories with several redundant ones. The only other type of useful categories with these rankings would be for players that once surpassed a certain threshold on the respective rankings (e.g. "SSBMRank Top 10", "UltRank top 50", etc.), since it could be useful to catalog players who were once "Top X in the world according to this ranking", and would be of clear interest to readers, while also not necessarily being immediately accessible information elsewhere. If those ranking threshold categories are added, they would carry the caveat of "on smasher articles, only include the category of the highest threshold the player has surpassed on that ranking" (so for example if a player was once top 10, don't include any of the other lower threshold ranking categories for them, as it would be redundant).

The only benefit I see of the current setup with the specific iterations ranking categories is that they do let you know what iterations the player made that particular ranking on, when you would otherwise need to manually check each ranking to see if they were ranked that specific iteration. However, this information would be much more effectively shown by creating a new "Rankings" section on smasher articles, which would show each ranking the player ever made. This would be immensely better than the current setup with the categories for the following reasons:

1: It would be much neater than a big blob of categories at the bottom of the page.

2: It would show the player's actual placing on that ranking, instead of requiring you to go to the ranking's article to see it.

3: It would display other information that would not be shown in the categories, such as the time range the ranking covered and the characters used by the player to make that ranking.

4: It can cover all other sorts of rankings instead of just global rankings.

Here is a very partially complete example table for Dabuz showing what it could look like, using just the Smash 4 PGR:

{|class="wikitable"
!Ranking!!Time period!!Rank!!Character(s)
|-
|[[PGR v1]]||January 2015 - May 2016||3rd||{{head|Rosalina|g=SSB4|s=20px}}
|-
|[[PGR v2]]||May 2016 - December 2016||4th||{{head|Rosalina|g=SSB4|s=20px}}{{head|Olimar|g=SSB4|s=20px}}
|-
|[[PGR v3]]||January 2017 = June 2017||4th||{{head|Rosalina|g=SSB4|s=20px}}{{head|Olimar|g=SSB4|s=20px}}
|-
|[[PGR v4]]||June 2017 - December 2017||6th||{{head|Rosalina|g=SSB4|s=20px}}{{head|Olimar|g=SSB4|s=20px}}
|-
|[[PGR v5]]||January 2018 - July 2018||3rd||{{head|Rosalina|g=SSB4|s=20px}}{{head|Olimar|g=SSB4|s=20px}}
|-
|[[PGR 100]]||January 2015 - November 2018||4th||{{head|Rosalina|g=SSB4|s=20px}}{{head|Olimar|g=SSB4|s=20px}}
|}

Like with results, you can make subsections for each game in this new rankings section, and I can iron out later how to organize multiple different rankings within a single game subsection, but I think we can all agree this looks way better than having categories for each of these individual rankings and throwing them on Dabuz's page.

So with that all said, here are the following options for what we'll do going forward. <span style="font-family:Edwardian Script ITC; font-size:12pt">[[User:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Omega</span>]] [[User talk:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Tyrant</span>]]</span> [[File: TyranitarMS.png ]] 06:53, April 3, 2023 (EDT)

==Keep the status quo==
#''...''

==Have a single category for each global ranking and nothing more==
#'''Support.''' The rankings section will be a more useful replacement. --[[User:Meester Tweester|Meester Tweester]] ([[User talk:Meester Tweester|talk]]) 14:50, April 3, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support.''' I don't know how well the threshold-based categories will work since I feel like our skill parameters already do a better job at noting the skill level of a player, and will be the ones that most players would look at since it's at the start of the page. [[User:Cookies and Creme|<span style="font-family: Georgia;color: black;">Cookies</span>]][[File:CnC Signature.png|20px]][[User talk:Cookies and Creme|<span style="font-family: Georgia; color: black;">Creme</span>]] 16:00, April 3, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support'''. I forgot about my talk page post on Dinodomain's post, but I think my concern back then was that it felt very unnecessary and would only get worse as time went by (which ended up becoming true). Things started to get really problematic with the introduction of the entirely arbitrary "Top 25" categories for each individual ranking. I think this would definitely be a much better alternative. [[User:PokemonMasterJamal3|PokemonMasterJamal3]] ([[User talk:PokemonMasterJamal3|talk]]) 09:04, April 4, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support'''. Those "top" categories pretty much bloat up a lot of smasher categories because there are multiple thresholds and iterations of rankings. I think they are rather unnecessary and a ranking table will get the job done better. [[File:Grand Dad.png|23x20px]] [[User:NaughtyPigMario|<span style="color: red;">'''NPM'''</span>]]  [[User talk:NaughtyPigMario|''<span style="color: blue;">Morr!?</span>'']] [[File:NaughtyPigBoi.jpg|23x20px]] 01:10, April 6, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support'''. Long overdue. [[User:SenorMexicano|<span style="color:#850FFA; text-shadow: 0px 0px 3px green">'''Señor'''</span> <span style="color:#850FFA;text-shadow:0px 0px 3px green">'''Mexicano'''</span>]] ''[[User talk:SenorMexicano|<span style="color:lightpurple;text-shadow:0px 0px 2px lightgreen">(talk)</span>]]'' 17:22, April 7, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support''', this is a great idea and will get rid of some bloat. [[User:Wiifitkid|Wiifitkid]] ([[User talk:Wiifitkid|talk]]) 17:05, April 8, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support''', nothing more to add. [[User:Rdrfc|Rdrfc]] ([[User talk:Rdrfc|talk]]) 13:37, April 11, 2023 (EDT)

==Remove specific iteration categories and add the respective threshold-based categories==
#''...''

==Get rid of any sort of ranking-based category==
#''...''

==Add a rankings section to smasher articles==
"Vote" on this separately from the category issue, I don't see a reason to not do this regardless of what we do with the categories, but I should open it up to a formal proposal anyway since we never done it on smasher articles before. <span style="font-family:Edwardian Script ITC; font-size:12pt">[[User:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Omega</span>]] [[User talk:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Tyrant</span>]]</span> [[File: TyranitarMS.png ]] 06:53, April 3, 2023 (EDT)

===Support===
#'''Support.''' --[[User:Meester Tweester|Meester Tweester]] ([[User talk:Meester Tweester|talk]]) 14:50, April 3, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support.''' Liquipedia has been doing this for a while and I found it really useful. [[User:Cookies and Creme|<span style="font-family: Georgia;color: black;">Cookies</span>]][[File:CnC Signature.png|20px]][[User talk:Cookies and Creme|<span style="font-family: Georgia; color: black;">Creme</span>]] 16:00, April 3, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support.''' As stated above, Liquipedia has been doing it for a while and it's very convenient. [[User:PokemonMasterJamal3|PokemonMasterJamal3]] ([[User talk:PokemonMasterJamal3|talk]]) 09:04, April 4, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support.''' A ranking table is a more convenient and less bloated way to demonstrate each player ranks. Similarly, I tried making a Smashmate ratings table for a player because the info is available. Plus having so many categories can only get really messy for some long-term players. [[File:Grand Dad.png|23x20px]] [[User:NaughtyPigMario|<span style="color: red;">'''NPM'''</span>]]  [[User talk:NaughtyPigMario|''<span style="color: blue;">Morr!?</span>'']] [[File:NaughtyPigBoi.jpg|23x20px]] 01:10, April 6, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support.''' Would make a very useful addition. Perhaps longer sections should be collapsible to avoid bloat. (For example M2K) [[User:SenorMexicano|<span style="color:#850FFA; text-shadow: 0px 0px 3px green">'''Señor'''</span> <span style="color:#850FFA;text-shadow:0px 0px 3px green">'''Mexicano'''</span>]] ''[[User talk:SenorMexicano|<span style="color:lightpurple;text-shadow:0px 0px 2px lightgreen">(talk)</span>]]'' 17:22, April 7, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support''', this is a great idea. Rankings are very annoying to navigate and this provides a lot of useful information to the reader. [[User:Wiifitkid|Wiifitkid]] ([[User talk:Wiifitkid|talk]]) 17:05, April 8, 2023 (EDT)
#’’’Support’’’, gives a good way to see a player’s ranking history which is quite helpful info [[User:Ninja1167|Ninja1167]] ([[User talk:Ninja1167|talk]]) 11:24, April 11, 2023 (EDT)
#'''Support''', this should probably be implemented as a new template similar to the one used for PR tables, so it can be easier to use. [[User:Rdrfc|Rdrfc]] ([[User talk:Rdrfc|talk]]) 13:37, April 11, 2023 (EDT)
===Oppose===
#''...''

==Comments==
I've brought this up in discord but only concern I may have with is some ranking systems (such as braacket or Smashmate) don't include all the information above. Smashmate also has information that is useful and pertinent (ratings) which is unique to it and other ladders, that should be incorporated. [[User:Wiifitkid|Wiifitkid]] ([[User talk:Wiifitkid|talk]]) 17:05, April 8, 2023 (EDT)

Bumping this for a last call, I'll be passing both parts of this proposal within 24-48 hours if no serious opposition arises to the consensus. <span style="font-family:Edwardian Script ITC; font-size:12pt">[[User:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Omega</span>]] [[User talk:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Tyrant</span>]]</span> [[File: TyranitarMS.png ]] 11:04, April 11, 2023 (EDT)

I put this off for a while, but this proposal is officially going through and the following actions will be taken:

*All categories for rankings will be removed from smasher pages and deleted. In their place, we will have only one category for each global ranking, which will be applied to the smasher articles of all players who were ever officially on at least one iteration of that ranking.

*We will start adding rankings sections to smasher articles. I'll update [[SW:SMASHER|our smasher article guidelines]] shortly to reflect this.

If there are any more questions, I can be asked here or on discord. <span style="font-family:Edwardian Script ITC; font-size:12pt">[[User:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Omega</span>]] [[User talk:Omega Tyrant|<span style="color:forestgreen">Tyrant</span>]]</span> [[File: TyranitarMS.png ]] 09:28, May 5, 2023 (EDT)
	You aren't logged in. While it's not a requirement to create an account, doing so makes it a lot easier to keep track of your edits and a lot harder to confuse you with someone else. If you edit without being logged in, your IP address will be recorded in the page's edit history.
	Log in	Create account
Insert common text
Signature	~~~~
Symbols	£ ¥ ° ± × ÷ € ≈ ≠ ≤ ≥
Diacritics	À Á Â Ã Ä Å Æ Ç È É Ê Ë Ì Í Î Ï Ð Ñ Ò Ó Ô Õ Ö Ø Œ Ù Ú Û Ü Ý Þ ß à á â ã ä å æ ç è é ê ë ì í î ï ð ñ ò ó ô õ ö ø œ ù ú û ü ý þ ÿ
Wikitext	[] [[]] \| [[Category:]] [[File:]] #REDIRECT: [[]] {\| \|- \|\| \|}
Templates	{{cleanup}} {{image}} {{reflist}} {{stub}} {{d}} {{delete}}
Formatting	<!----> <br> <code></code> <gallery></gallery> <nowiki></nowiki> <ref></ref> <references/> {{#widget:YouTube\|id=}}
Substitution	<includeonly></includeonly> <noinclude></noinclude>