Talk:Smash wiki: Difference between revisions
From SmashWiki, the Super Smash Bros. wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (→deletion) |
(→deletion: Reply.) |
||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
'''Oppose''' You have an article on [[Super Smash Flash]], so, OBVIOUSLY, you should keep this. ;) - [[User:Pokemon DP|Pokemon DP]] | '''Oppose''' You have an article on [[Super Smash Flash]], so, OBVIOUSLY, you should keep this. ;) - [[User:Pokemon DP|Pokemon DP]] | ||
:but you could use that same argument to justify [[Duck World|this joke of an article]]. '''[[User:Silverdragon706|FyreNWater]]''' - <small>([[User talk:Silverdragon706|Talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/FyreNWater|Contributions]] )</small> 02:52, November 13, 2007 (EST) | :but you could use that same argument to justify [[Duck World|this joke of an article]]. '''[[User:Silverdragon706|FyreNWater]]''' - <small>([[User talk:Silverdragon706|Talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/FyreNWater|Contributions]] )</small> 02:52, November 13, 2007 (EST) | ||
::Duck world is a vandalism-only page with no relevance to the Smash Bros. community, and hence warrants deletion IMHO. This page, while clearly created as a vandalism attempt, could suffice as a redirect to [[SmashWiki:About]]; after all, [[SmashWiki]] is a redirect to there too. | |||
::In contrast, Super Smash Flash is apparently quite an important thing to the Smash Bros. series, and this wiki is clearly meant to document things that are important to the community regardless of how "encyclopedically non-feeling" they might be, unlike the actual Wikipedia itself; therefore, it looks like the only thing a subject needs to be in order to get covered by SmashWiki is that it IS important in some way to the Smash Bros. community, and pages that fulfill that condition therefore are pages on players of the games, playable characters confirmed on DOJO, the DOJO site itself, etc.. That's why, as one of Wikipedia's established "serious editors", I say that Flash article in particular's fine to have on this wiki. [[User:Erik the Appreciator|Erik, Lord of Universes]] 03:14, November 13, 2007 (EST) | |||
Revision as of 04:14, November 13, 2007
deletion
Strong delete if you're here, you should know what the SmashWiki is by now. seriously. FyreNWater - (Talk • Contributions ) 22:15, November 12, 2007 (EST)
Oppose You have an article on Super Smash Flash, so, OBVIOUSLY, you should keep this. ;) - Pokemon DP
- but you could use that same argument to justify this joke of an article. FyreNWater - (Talk • Contributions ) 02:52, November 13, 2007 (EST)
- Duck world is a vandalism-only page with no relevance to the Smash Bros. community, and hence warrants deletion IMHO. This page, while clearly created as a vandalism attempt, could suffice as a redirect to SmashWiki:About; after all, SmashWiki is a redirect to there too.
- In contrast, Super Smash Flash is apparently quite an important thing to the Smash Bros. series, and this wiki is clearly meant to document things that are important to the community regardless of how "encyclopedically non-feeling" they might be, unlike the actual Wikipedia itself; therefore, it looks like the only thing a subject needs to be in order to get covered by SmashWiki is that it IS important in some way to the Smash Bros. community, and pages that fulfill that condition therefore are pages on players of the games, playable characters confirmed on DOJO, the DOJO site itself, etc.. That's why, as one of Wikipedia's established "serious editors", I say that Flash article in particular's fine to have on this wiki. Erik, Lord of Universes 03:14, November 13, 2007 (EST)
