Forum:Uh... Peach?
Okay, seriously. I need someone to tell me why people won't shut up about Peach. What the hell is so special about her? She's not that good! Not in Melee, and definitely not in Brawl! So she can float... whoop-de-freakin'-do! She can't do vertical recoveries! Let's face it, if your light, weak, and you can't gain any height, you shouldn't be anywhere near the top tier. I'm hoping in the Brawl tier list that the professionals won't make the mistake of placing her there again. PEACH SUCKS! It's about time someone said it! - GalaxiaD 01:54, 3 May 2008 (UTC)
I agree 100%. About the only thing she has going for her is her floating, which is predictable anyway. I have no idea why she was top tier in Melee. Theres really nothing good about her at all. I hope in Brawl that shes not top tier again. Not to mention the fact that I just hate Peach anyway. Meta Knight and Pit sound more like top tier material to me. --Danbatista 02:37, 3 May 2008 (UTC)
- I wouldn't say she SUCKS, but she does seem to have more...ahem...whiny fanboys than most characters... - Gargomon251 03:18, 3 May 2008 (UTC)
- Even though I think Peach is bad, some players are really good with her. Also, I won't put down any more characters (such as Peach), as it tends to lead to people whining. --Danbatista 05:23, 3 May 2008 (UTC)
You're right. We definitely don't need any more whining than what has already occured. I also agree with you on Meta Knight and Pit being the top two. They're relatively fast, they both glide, they both have great recovery ability, etc. Overall, Meta Knight and Pit have the greatest potential. - GalaxiaD 05:49, 3 May 2008 (UTC)
Well what About Marth or King Dedede? They both are quite good; Marth has an impressive dash, his Counter last quite some time, and he has a wide move set. King Dedede has some of the strongest smash moves, and sure their slow, but think, with the use of items that problem is (Pretty much) fixed. And Besides, he's really tough to KO, Period. And I think the only reason Peach was good was on certain stages, it gave her the advantage. Some of these stages were Mute City to dodge vehicles, or Icicle Mountain to keep from falling behind. The only other good thing about her floaty ability is she can get some horazontal distance, but with her weight anyways, your probrably not going to be able to use it anyways. Learner4 20:50, 3 May 2008 (UTC)
Marth will definitely be a high tier character, but he might come just a little short of qualifying for top tier. Also, King Dedede may be a very strong character, but in tournaments, he will have no items to help him, therefore making him vulnerable to comboes. His ability to jump four times in the air, however, does come in handy, so he'll definitely be in the middle tier. Peach, on the other hand, should be placed in the low or bottom tier. In tournaments, Icicle Mountain is banned, so that eliminates one of her advantages. Also, in Brawl, the very few strong attacks she had have been nerfed, especially her down smash. Basically, the people who make tiers need to focus more on the actual metagame of the characters, not their specific stage advantages. It's not guaranteed that the character's best stage will be picked, but said character's metagame is a constant factor. It's more about skill, not luck, so stages shouldn't be considered when forming a tier list. - GalaxiaD 00:00, 4 May 2008 (UTC)
