Talk:Zinger

Keep, not just this but the remaining batch of Smash Tour items. Most of them have pages anyway for other reasons, with a very scant few that are "only" Smash Tour items. Considering this is a closed set with only a few pages involved, and doesn't open the floodgates the way "every trophy/sticker/spirit" would, it seems like a harmless and reasonable set of pages to keep. Plus it makes the nav template look nicer to have the whole batch be actual pages. Miles (talk) 14:19, March 29, 2023 (EDT)

You do make a decent point that it's relatively harmless given how small the amount of smash tour-only characters there are, and I didn't realize there was that nav template. Even in that context, it's entirely possible for some to get a major appearance later on, such as Dixie and Black Knight getting mii costumes in ssb4 dlc and ultimate. I was under the impression that these shouldn't count given that they are essentially just spirits and low-effort to develop, but the small amount is definitely a point in its favor. Unnamed anon (talk) 18:02, March 29, 2023 (EDT)

I'll point out that "there isn't much of them" and "they're harmless" is a terrible argument for keeping articles, as that could be applied to any singular article that ever got deleted, and "why not?" shouldn't be used to argue for things on the wiki in general. However, this isn't a good place to argue for these pages being kept/deleted, and I'm going to make a new post in the forum these pages were originally deemed ok for a more centralized discussion on our standards for character articles. Omega Tyrant 22:13, March 29, 2023 (EDT)