26
edits
SmashWiki:Featured content: Difference between revisions
→Palutena's Guidance
m (support) |
Reversinator (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 56: | Line 56: | ||
:'''Weak oppose''' I have to agree that it's really just a list of quotes ripped directly from ''SSB4''. Not that it's not an interesting article all the same. [[User:BaconMaster|<span style="color: Crimson;">'''Bacon'''</span>]][[User talk:BaconMaster|<span style="color: Maroon;">'''Master'''</span>]][[File:BaconMasterSig.png|16px|link=]] 16:27, 1 July 2016 (EDT) | :'''Weak oppose''' I have to agree that it's really just a list of quotes ripped directly from ''SSB4''. Not that it's not an interesting article all the same. [[User:BaconMaster|<span style="color: Crimson;">'''Bacon'''</span>]][[User talk:BaconMaster|<span style="color: Maroon;">'''Master'''</span>]][[File:BaconMasterSig.png|16px|link=]] 16:27, 1 July 2016 (EDT) | ||
:'''Oppose''' I don't believe this is actually a good example of SmashWiki's excellence, which is what we are looking for in a featured article, due to the lack of prose. Plus, most of the Support votes aren't really about the article, but the Guidenece itself, which really isn't the point. [[File:PenroImage.png|19px]][[User:Penro|<font color="red">'''Pen'''</font><font color="black">'''''ro'''''</font>]] 13:34, 8 July 2016 (EDT) | :'''Oppose''' I don't believe this is actually a good example of SmashWiki's excellence, which is what we are looking for in a featured article, due to the lack of prose. Plus, most of the Support votes aren't really about the article, but the Guidenece itself, which really isn't the point. [[File:PenroImage.png|19px]][[User:Penro|<font color="red">'''Pen'''</font><font color="black">'''''ro'''''</font>]] 13:34, 8 July 2016 (EDT) | ||
:'''Oppose''': The article only occasionally elaborates on some of the detalis brought up in conversations (the Koopalings mystery, Link and Pit being released on the same year, etc.) and not others (the "ninjas that just eats very slowly" comment with Greninja, Falco being the leader of a galactic gang, "DO A BARREL ROLL!" with Fox, etc.). This is especially important since the article links to the characters' playstyle in SSB4 and not the "main" articles that actually have their backstory. Beyond that, some of the existing writing is a bit clunky in places; it's noticeable with the notes for Meta Knight, Samus, Shulk, WFTrainer, Yoshi, and especially Wario, though it wouldn't take much to clean it up. The lack of images doesn't help it much, either. | |||
===[[Fox (SSBM)]]=== | ===[[Fox (SSBM)]]=== | ||