Category talk:Pit players

Definition of "character-specific"

When I added all the "Category:(Character) professionals" to Category:Character specific professionals, I assumed that the latter category was supposed to be a sort of directory to professional smashers that played a specific character, not a label for professionals that only focused on one character e.g. if I wanted to find a Fox professional, I could view Category:Character specific professionals, click on Category:Fox professionals, and then find Smasher:Masashi, who would also be under Category:Ganondorf professionals. This is because we don't have a category for professionals in general, and it seemed to make sense to add all the "Category:(Character) professionals" pages to that category instead. On closer inspection of the description of the Category:Character specific professionals page, it seemed like the original intent was to highlight professionals who had brought "advancement of metagame to their characters". However, the description seems too subjective. I propose adding the Category:(Character) professionals pages to a new Category:Professionals page instead. Mousehunter321 (talk) 17:33, 20 November 2011 (EST)

From the name, I presumed Character specific professionals was a category for players who only play a specific character, rather than a repository for the various character mains. I agree we should create a "Professionals" category that fulfills what the Character specific professional was intended for, and then use the Character specific professional category for smashers that only play one, specific character competitively, as its name suggests. Omega Tyrant 18:00, 20 November 2011 (EST)

I just discovered Category:Pros. We don't need a Category:Professionals, except as a redirect. Mousehunter321 (talk) 23:12, 20 November 2011 (EST)